Supreme Court Lets 22 Prohibited-Person Gun Bans Stand Untouched
On November 9, the Supreme Court declined to hear 22 Second Amendment cases dealing with prohibited-person gun laws, leaving every challenged restriction in place and letting the issue sit for another term.
Snapshot
Bearing Arms columnist Tom Knighton looks at a single morning's orders list in which the Court turned away 16 felon-gun-ban challenges plus cases on a misdemeanor-DUI gun ban, the federal ban on receiving firearms while under indictment, and a lifetime ban tied to a misdemeanor domestic-violence conviction. No justice noted a dissent.
Key points
- What was denied: Cases named in the piece include Foster v. United States and Barge v. United States, both challenging permanent bans built on nonviolent felonies; Holloway v. Brown, over Washington's gun ban after a second DUI in seven years; Trevino v. United States, on 18 U.S.C. § 922(n)'s ban for people under indictment; and Minor v. United States, on a lifetime ban from a misdemeanor domestic-violence conviction.
- Same day, different treatment: The Court used the same orders list to let the Solicitor General argue alongside gun owners in the December 2 AR-15 rifle-ban cases, which Knighton notes shows the Court is willing to engage on some Second Amendment fights.
- No merits ruling: Denying cert isn't a ruling on the merits, but Knighton argues the lack of any dissent suggests the justices see no urgency to revisit these laws.
- Rahimi shadow: Knighton points to the Court's Rahimi decision as evidence the justices aren't inclined to side with people flagged as dangerous, even in misdemeanor cases like Minor.
Quick take
Knighton's own view is that nonviolent felons and DUI offenders shouldn't face permanent bans, and that if conduct is serious enough to strip rights for life, it should have been charged as a felony to begin with. He says he isn't surprised by the outcome, just unpersuaded by it.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com