Gator's Guns Magazine Case Stalls Until Supreme Court Rules in 2027
If you've been wondering why Washington Gun Law hasn't posted an update on the Gator's Custom Guns magazine case in a while, William Kirk has an answer: there's nothing new to report because the case is parked, and it's likely to stay that way until mid-2027.
Snapshot
Kirk explains that the Supreme Court is holding Gator's Custom Guns, along with two other magazine-related cases, while it hears oral arguments in two separate assault-weapons cases, Vermont and Grant, set for December 2. His prediction: once those rulings land, the Court will likely GVR Gator's back down to the Washington State Supreme Court for a do-over.
Key points
- Five cases, one holding pattern: Kirk tracks Gator's Custom Guns alongside Duncan v. Bonta, NAGR v. Lamont, Vermont v. Cook County, and Grant v. Higgins, noting the Court accepted only the two assault-weapons cases for argument while freezing the rest.
- GVR expected around summer 2027: Kirk says a ruling in Vermont and Grant is expected late June or early July 2027, after which Gator's would be sent back to the Washington State Supreme Court to reconsider the magazine ban under whatever new rules the Court announces.
- A wildcard from New Jersey: Kirk flags Davenport v. ANJRPC, where the Third Circuit struck down New Jersey's magazine and assault-weapons bans, directly conflicting with Washington's ruling on nearly every legal point.
- Lawyers pushing for speed: Clement and Murphy, representing Gator's with Silent Majority Foundation, filed a supplemental brief urging the Court to take up the magazine issue now rather than wait, given the circuit split.
- History tempers optimism: Kirk recalls that the 2022 round of post-Bruen GVRs didn't change outcomes in lower courts, suggesting a similar GVR here may not guarantee a different result in Washington.
Quick take
Kirk's update is less about new wins and more about managing expectations: the Gator's case isn't dead, it's just waiting on the Supreme Court's calendar, and patience through 2027 is the realistic outlook.
Watch the full video: Washington Gun Law