ATF Faces Scrutiny Over Destroyed Guns of Pardoned Pastor
A presidential pardon was supposed to give Pastor Russell Fincher his life back, but it couldn't give him back more than 50 firearms the ATF says it already destroyed.
Snapshot
ATF Director Robert Cekada reportedly told Oklahoma pastor Russell Fincher this week that agency staff destroyed every firearm seized from him, even though President Trump later pardoned him. Fincher, convicted on a gun charge, is now asking for proof the destruction actually happened, according to Bearing Arms.
Key points
- The collection: The ATF took more than 50 personal firearms from Fincher, including a Wilson Combat, five Glocks, and a Polytech pre-ban milled under-folder AK worth thousands.
- Conflicting timeline: Bearing Arms notes reports place the destruction in either June or August 2026, with no clarity on whether it was recorded on video.
- Fincher's doubt: Fincher says he's not accusing Cekada directly but wants evidence, telling Bearing Arms, "Prove to me—show me the evidence they were destroyed—show me the video."
- Outside scrutiny: The Second Amendment Foundation has filed a FOIA request seeking records on what actually happened to the firearms.
- The property question: Bearing Arms' Tom Knighton argues Fincher still legally owned the guns and should have been allowed to designate someone else to take or sell them instead of having them destroyed.
Quick take
A pardon can erase a conviction, but it can't un-melt a gun. If the ATF destroyed lawfully owned property before exhausting options like third-party transfer, that's a due process problem worth tracking, pardon or not. The FOIA request and Fincher's push for documentation are the next things to watch here.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com