Gun Rights

Sixth Circuit Upholds Gun Ban for Mentally Ill Under Bruen Test

November 16, 2026

The Sixth Circuit has upheld the federal ban on gun possession by people adjudicated as mentally defective, finding the law survives Second Amendment scrutiny under Bruen.

Snapshot

On October 29, 2026, a Sixth Circuit panel rejected a facial challenge to 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(4) in the case of Alexander Laykovich, who was convicted under the law after a 2024 traffic stop near Fort Knox turned up eight firearms, body armor, and fentanyl. The court found the prohibition fits within historical traditions of restricting firearms access for people found dangerous due to mental illness, according to Bearing Arms.

Key points

  • The case: Laykovich was involuntarily committed by a Missouri court in 2023 after being found a danger to himself or others, and never petitioned to have his firearms ban lifted.
  • The stop: In January 2024, Kentucky officers pulled him over for erratic driving and found eight guns, ammunition, knives, a gas can, marijuana and fentanyl, leading to charges under 922(g)(4).
  • The ruling: Judge Eric Murphy, writing for the panel, held the government met its burden at Bruen's historical-analogue step by pointing to a long tradition of confining the dangerously mentally ill.
  • The unresolved question: The court itself noted 922(g)(4) gives no clear standard for what mental illness qualifies, per Bearing Arms, but Laykovich's facial challenge failed because he couldn't show the law could never apply constitutionally.

Quick take

Bearing Arms' Tom Knighton says he's torn on this one, acknowledging society has long restricted liberty for those judged a danger to themselves or others, while also flagging that the law's vague definition of "mentally defective" leaves real due-process gaps. He argues Laykovich is a poor test case for gun-rights advocates, but notes that if this reaches the Supreme Court, the ruling could end up reshaping red flag laws in either direction.

Read the full story: bearingarms.com