Gun Rights

Lawyer: Connecticut Misreads Old English Gun Laws in SCOTUS AR-15 Case

November 15, 2026

Connecticut's defense of its "assault weapons" ban at the Supreme Court leans heavily on medieval English gun laws, but Second Amendment lawyer Alan Beck says the state is misreading what those old laws actually did.

Snapshot

In a podcast interview with The Reload's Stephen Gutowski, attorney Alan Beck critiques Connecticut's historical-analogue brief in the Supreme Court's AR-15 ban case. Beck, who recently won Wolford v. Lopez, argues the state mischaracterizes old English restrictions on weapons like lancegays, steelets, and handguns as broad bans when they were mostly carry or anti-poaching rules.

Key points

  • The analogue problem: Beck says Connecticut's brief treats centuries-old English laws as outright weapon bans, but he argues most were restrictions on carrying or poaching, not possession.
  • Why it matters: Under the Court's Bruen framework, states must point to historical analogues to justify modern gun restrictions, making the accuracy of these old laws central to the case.
  • Misleading intent, Beck argues: He contends Connecticut's brief is unclear not just on how these laws functioned, but on the actual reasons lawmakers enacted them at the time.
  • What's next: Beck and Gutowski discuss how the Court might rule, with the midterm elections and the possibility of new state AR-15 bans factoring into the timing and stakes.
  • Another case to watch: Beck says a new circuit split could push one of his other Second Amendment cases toward the Supreme Court as well.

Quick take

Historical analogues have become the battleground in post-Bruen litigation, and this interview is a useful reminder that the sourcing behind those arguments deserves scrutiny from both sides. Beck's critique, as reported by The Reload, is worth hearing in full if you're tracking how this case could reshape "assault weapons" bans nationwide.

Read the full story: thereload.com