Gun Rights

SCOTUS Leaves Maryland's Gun-Free Zones Intact Despite Thomas's Doubts

November 16, 2026

The Supreme Court declined to hear Novotny v. Moore on Monday, leaving the Fourth Circuit's ruling on Maryland's "sensitive places" law mostly intact, with gun-free zones in museums and certain state buildings staying in place while parks, forests, and entertainment venues remain on shakier constitutional footing.

Snapshot

The denial means Maryland's patchwork of carry restrictions survives for now, even though the Fourth Circuit itself flagged parks, forests, and entertainment venues as constitutionally questionable under Bruen's historical-tradition test. Justice Clarence Thomas wrote separately, agreeing with the denial but acknowledging doubts about whether every one of these laws has real historical backing, according to Bearing Arms.

Key points

  • Mixed appellate result: The Fourth Circuit upheld bans in museums and some state-controlled buildings but found the restrictions on parks, forests, and entertainment venues vulnerable under Bruen's historical-tradition test.
  • Thomas flags the problem but won't force the issue: Thomas wrote that challenging a broad mix of statutes at once "complicates" the Court's review, even while admitting the laws rest on shaky historical ground, Bearing Arms reports.
  • Other states have gone further: Bearing Arms notes New Jersey bans guns in 25-plus locations, New York in 20, and California in 29, covering everything from libraries to athletic facilities.
  • Related denial same day: The Court also turned away Colie v. Commonwealth of Virginia, leaving intact a conviction against a concealed carrier acquitted on self-defense shooting charges but convicted of unlawful discharge in an occupied building.

Quick take

Bearing Arms' Cam Edwards argues this was the case to use for a broad ruling, and that waiting for a "narrower" vehicle just lets more states stack sensitive-place restrictions indefinitely. That's a real concern for anyone trying to carry lawfully through an ordinary day in a blue state.

Read the full story: bearingarms.com