Personal Defense

Wisconsin Homeowner, 75, Fatally Shoots Man Forcing His Way In

November 18, 2026

A 75-year-old man in Oneida County, Wisconsin shot and killed a 35-year-old man early Sunday morning after the man allegedly grabbed his glasses and tried to force his way through the front door.

Snapshot

According to Bearing Arms, the suspect had already pushed his way into an elderly woman's home nearby before pounding on Marshall Robinson's door around 1 AM. Robinson armed himself, opened the door to ask who was there, and fired when the man grabbed at his glasses and tried to shove inside. The suspect died at the scene.

Key points

  • Prior incident: The suspect, identified as 35-year-old James Roath, had reportedly entered an elderly neighbor's home, pounded and kicked her door after she got him out, then wandered to Robinson's house.
  • Threshold confrontation: Robinson opened his door to see who was pounding on it, and Roath grabbed his glasses and tried to force his way inside, prompting Robinson to fire.
  • Outcome: Deputies and medical personnel attempted lifesaving measures, but Roath was pronounced dead at the scene; the Oneida County Sheriff's Office continued investigating.
  • Legal backing: Bearing Arms notes Wisconsin law presumes deadly force is reasonable when someone is forcibly entering or has forcibly entered a home and the defender believes that's happening.
  • Author's take: Bearing Arms' Cam Edwards argues Robinson had no way to know the stranger's intentions and was right not to risk finding out firsthand.

Quick take

Robinson didn't go looking for trouble; it came pounding on his door at 1 AM. Opening that door to a stranger who'd already forced his way into one home put Robinson in a position where he had seconds to decide, and the law in his state backs the call he made.

Read the full story: bearingarms.com