Louisiana Law Backs Homeowner Who Shot Knife-Wielding Intruder
A Louisiana homeowner shot and killed a knife-wielding man who cut through a window screen and climbed into his house near Minden, and the local sheriff says charges against the homeowner are unlikely.
Snapshot
Webster Parish Sheriff Jason Parker said Billy McFarland, 44, forced his way into a home west of Minden early on Oct. 18 after a violent night that began with a domestic disturbance and a high-speed crash. The homeowner opened fire as McFarland came through the window still holding a knife, and the case now heads to the district attorney for a final charging decision.
Key points
- Chaotic lead-up: Authorities say a 911 call about a domestic disturbance in a moving vehicle on U.S. Highway 80 preceded a crash, after McFarland allegedly attacked the female driver.
- Break-in method: Investigators say McFarland left the crash scene, damaged two vehicles at a nearby home, then climbed onto an AC unit and used a pocket knife to slice a window screen to get inside.
- Armed entry: Sheriff Parker said McFarland still had the knife in hand when he came through the window, and the homeowner fired multiple times, apparently fearing for his own life and others in the house.
- Charges unlikely, for now: Parker's office expects no charges against the homeowner, but the investigation is ongoing and will be forwarded to the district attorney for the formal decision.
- Legal backdrop: Louisiana Revised Statutes 14:20 allows deadly force against unlawful, forcible entry into an occupied home, creating a presumption of reasonable fear in such cases.
Quick take
This is about as clean a defensive-use case as they come: a forced window entry, a visible weapon, and people inside the home. The sheriff's early read lines up with how Louisiana's justifiable-homicide law is written, but the case isn't closed until the district attorney weighs in.
Read the full story: concealednation.org