Gun Rights

Fifth Circuit Extends Second Amendment to Gun Sales, Not Just Ownership

November 20, 2026

A Fifth Circuit panel just ruled that the Second Amendment doesn't stop at owning a gun—it covers buying and selling one too, a finding that could complicate gun control schemes across the circuit.

Snapshot

In U.S. v. Deare, a three-judge panel reversed a lower court's refusal to dismiss federal charges against a man accused of dealing firearms without a license. The majority held that the plain text of the Second Amendment protects commercial gun sales, not just possession, and sent the case back to the district court, as Bearing Arms reports.

Key points

  • The ruling: Judges James Ho and Andrew Oldham formed the majority, holding that firearm acquisition rights are meaningless if the government can simply ban the means of exercising them.
  • The dissent: Judge Catharina Hayne argued the Second Amendment doesn't mention sellers, so they aren't covered, and that Deare hadn't properly challenged the rules at issue.
  • Ho's rebuttal: Ho compared Hayne's logic to arguing the First Amendment doesn't protect booksellers since they aren't named in the text either, calling that conclusion untenable.
  • Peterson limited: Oldham told the lower court to disregard the circuit's prior Peterson decision, which treated NFA registration as a "shall-issue" scheme entitled to a presumption of constitutionality—a reading Oldham said stretched a narrow Bruen footnote far beyond its context.
  • No remand off-ramp: Deare isn't off the hook yet, but the panel found the government failed to show a historical tradition comparable to restrictions forcing out-of-state handgun buyers through an in-state dealer.

Quick take

This is a meaningful crack in the wall separating "keep and bear" from "buy and sell," and Bearing Arms frames it as bad news for any Fifth Circuit state eyeing new sales restrictions. Worth watching how the district court handles the remand, and whether other circuits start citing Ho and Oldham's reasoning.

Read the full story: bearingarms.com